Polity Matters

Playlists

Interviews

Every episode with a guest.

86 episodes · about 73 hours

Subscribe to this playlist

This playlist has its own feed. Add it to your podcast app and these 86 episodes show up as their own show, in order.

https://www.politymatters.org/playlists/interviews/feed.xml

In Apple Podcasts you can also choose Library, then the menu, then "Follow a Show by URL" and paste the address. Spotify does not allow adding a feed by address.

  1. #2: You're Going to Hate Sausage Forever (BCO Preface II.1-3)

    September 12, 2023 · 50 minutes

    Scott, Jared, and Ben are joined by Steve Tipton in the first of two conversations about the PCA BCO Preliminary Principles.

  2. #3: I Thought This Would Be About Polity (BCO Preface II.4-8)

    September 19, 2023 · 40 minutes

    Scott, Jared, and Ben are joined by Steve Tipton as they conclude their discussions about the PCA BCO Preliminary Principles.

  3. #9: Big Ole Spreadsheet (BCO 5.1-5.8)

    October 31, 2023 · 66 minutes

    Ben and Jared are joined by Stephen and Jeremy to discuss the many details of Mission Churches from BCO 5.

  4. #10: You're a Church (BCO 5.9-5.10)

    November 7, 2023 · 55 minutes

    Ben is joined by Matt and another Ben to discuss Mission Churches in real life.

  5. #12: Who's the Half? (BCO 7)

    November 21, 2023 · 53 minutes

    Officers everywhere in BCO 7! A Scottless, Jaredless episode… but Steve Tipton jumps in to cover for them.

  6. #13: Called Meeting: RE Howie Donahoe

    November 23, 2023 · 44 minutes

    Jared sits down with RE Howie Donahoe to discuss churchmanship, including GA moderating all the way to how to write an overture.

  7. #14: I'm Very Interested In Plumbing (BCO 8.1-8.4)

    November 28, 2023 · 51 minutes

    The first annual Polity Matters Holiday Gift Guide is here! And also the guys are joined by TE Fred Greco to discuss BCO 8 on The Elder.

  8. #15: Interlopers or Conflicts, Etc. (BCO 8.5-8.10)

    December 5, 2023 · 43 minutes

    The polity bros resume their discussion with PCA Grand Poobah Fred Greco on BCO 8: The Elder.

  9. #17: Called Meeting: TE Adam Parker

    December 19, 2023 · 44 minutes

    TE Adam Parker joined Jared and Ben to discuss his recent article dealing with one of our apparent favorite topics: assistant pastors.

  10. #18: Interview with Jonny Gibson

    December 22, 2023 · 53 minutes

    Before we dive into Witherow’s The Apostolic Church next week, the bros sit down with Dr. Jonathan Gibson and discuss his study and work on Thomas Witherow.

  11. #20: Trying to Claim Apostolic Authority (Witherow's 1st Principle)

    January 9, 2024 · 50 minutes

    The polity bros are joined by kindred spirit Jacob Gerber to discuss Witherow’s first principle of the apostolic church: the Office-Bearers are Chosen by the People.

  12. #21: A Dungeon No One Would Ever Want to Be In (Witherow's 2nd Principle)

    January 16, 2024 · 44 minutes

    The Polity Triumvirate is joined by Rev. Jim McCarthy to discuss Witherow’s second principle of the apostolic church: the terms elder and bishop are identical.

  13. #22: You're Not Alone (Witherow's 3rd Principle)

    January 23, 2024 · 36 minutes

    Welcome to RE Joshua Torrey and apologies that we subjected him to a new game before discussing the third principle of the apostolic church: in each church there ought to be a plurality of elders.

  14. #23: You’re Not Smart Enough, Ben (Witherow’s 4th Principle)

    January 30, 2024 · 34 minutes

    We are pleased to be joined by Job Dalmoba today as we discuss the fourth principle of the apostolic church: ordination is the act of the presbytery–a plurality of elders.

  15. #24: Sloth Pelican (Witherow's 5th Principle)

    February 6, 2024 · 42 minutes

    With no intention of fulfilling any of their new years resolutions, our three hosts work through Witherow’s fourth principle with the help of Rev. Jason Piland.

  16. #25: Christian Nationalism (Witherow's 6th Principle)

    February 13, 2024 · 35 minutes

    Not as much Christian Nationalism in this episode as you’d expect. Joshua Walker joins us to discuss Witherow’s final principle of the Apostolic church.

  17. #35: Called Meeting: Everybody Has a Voice

    April 22, 2024 · 40 minutes

    Scott, Jared, and Ben are joined by Matthew Bradley and Nathan McCall of the Y’all Saints Podcast, and Adam Parker and Matthew Poole of The Evergreen Beaverton Podcast to discuss church polity for the church member.

  18. #36: Before the Gavel

    April 30, 2024 · 42 minutes

    Per Almquist joins to discuss matters related to General Assembly. He is the pastor of Free Grace Presbyterian Church in Lewiston, Maine.

  19. #37: Opening of Assembly

    May 7, 2024 · 61 minutes

    Our current PCA GA Moderator joins us to discuss what happens at the first meeting of the Assembly.

  20. #38: GA Committee Reports

    May 14, 2024 · 52 minutes

    A warm welcome to Mel Duncan as he discusses the work of the General Assembly with us. Oh, and we prove that Scott is not a robot.

  21. #39: 2024 GA Overtures Overview

    May 21, 2024 · 122 minutes

    DISCLAIMER: Only one person on this episode actually wrote an Overture that we discuss.

  22. #40: GA Overtures Committee

    May 28, 2024 · 43 minutes

    The men are joined by RE Steve Dowling to discuss the work of the Overtures Committee at the General Assembly.

  23. #41: Sausage & a Bible & Probably a Cask of Wine (RPR Deep Dive)

    May 31, 2024 · 67 minutes

    Steve Tipton steals the show with a thorough explanation of the General Assembly’s Review of Presbytery Records Committee.

  24. #43: Beside the GA Business

    June 10, 2024 · 57 minutes

    Welcome Sarah and Zoe to the show as they explain to Ben everything else about GA.

  25. #45: Bill Clerk for Another Year (ARP Roundup)

    July 2, 2024 · 52 minutes

    Ben and Jared are joined by ARP minister Benjamin Glaser for a roundup of everything from the 2024 General Synod of the Associate Reformed Presbyterians.

  26. #46: EPC Roundup

    July 16, 2024 · 51 minutes

    Ben and Jared are joined by Dustin Jernigan from the EPC to get the deets on their 2024 General Assembly.

  27. #47: OPC Roundup

    July 30, 2024 · 55 minutes

    The guys spend time hearing about the PCA’s long lost sister, the OPC. With guest Andrew Miller.

  28. #48: CRC Roundup

    August 13, 2024 · 55 minutes

    Scott and Ben catch up with Tyler Wagenmaker of the Christian Reformed Church, following their Synod meeting earlier this summer.

  29. #49: RPCNA Roundup

    August 27, 2024 · 44 minutes

    We are glad to welcome Nathan Eshelman to the show! He brings greetings and updates from the RPCNA.

  30. #50: Happy Birthday!

    September 10, 2024 · 64 minutes

    It’s our first birthday and we threw a party with some friends! Ryan Biese, Steve Tipton, and Fred Greco joined us for some fun and festivities as we celebrated this milestone. Enjoy!

  31. #59: [Insert Title Here] (BCO 21 Part 1)

    November 12, 2024 · 45 minutes

    Steve joins Ben and Jared to discuss BCO 21 on the Ordination and Installation of minister.

  32. #60: As the Prayer Goes Longer and Longer (BCO 21 Part 2)

    November 19, 2024 · 30 minutes

    Ordination services! Ben, Jared, and Steve finish up BCO 21.

  33. #62: Good Faith Subscription with David Strain

    November 26, 2024 · 65 minutes

    Jared, Scott, and Ben are joined by David Strain to discuss good faith subscription in the PCA.

  34. #68: Potentially Edifying (Ordination Questions with Groff)

    January 13, 2025 · 89 minutes

    In this episode of Polity Matters, Ben Ratliff, Jared Nelson, Scott Edburg, and special guest Zachary Groff take a deep dive into the ordination vows for teaching elders in the Presbyterian Church in America (PCA). The conversation explores the significance of each vow, offering practical insights and theological reflections for ministers and members alike.

  35. #70: Motion to Reconsider: Assistant Pastors

    February 4, 2025 · 44 minutes

    In this special installment of Motion to Reconsider, we return to our interview with TE Adam Parker regarding his article on Assistant Pastors.

  36. #71: Procedural Checklist (w/T. David Gordon)

    February 11, 2025 · 57 minutes

    Procedural Checklist for PCA BCO Rules of Discipline

  37. #72: Chapter 27 is Chiastic (BCO 27)

    February 18, 2025 · 66 minutes

    Steve Dowling joins Ben, Jared, and Scott to discuss BCO 27 on the nature, subjects, and ends of church discipline.

  38. #73: The Jared Nelson Memorial Episode (BCO 28)

    February 25, 2025 · 52 minutes

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Tipton —the fourth polity bro— to discuss BCO 28: Disciplining of Non-communing Members.

  39. #74: Just Give Me Another Hour (BCO 29)

    March 4, 2025 · 35 minutes

    In this episode of Polity Matters, hosts Ben Ratliff, Jared Nelson, and Scott Edberg welcome Ruling Elder John Bise to discuss Chapter 29 of the PCA Book of Church Order: Offenses.

  40. #75: Pure Hypothetical (BCO 30)

    March 11, 2025 · 55 minutes

    In this episode of Polity Matters, hosts Ben Ratliff, Jared Nelson, and Scott Edberg welcome Dr. Guy Waters of Reformed Theological Seminary to discuss Chapter 30 of the PCA Book of Church Order (BCO), which deals with church censures. They explore the biblical, theological, and practical aspects of church discipline, the different types of censures available to church courts, and how they should be wisely applied in the life of the church.

  41. #76: Story Time with Steve (BCO 31 part one)

    March 18, 2025 · 64 minutes

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Tipton to dive into BCO 31, which outlines the key players and procedures involved in formal judicial processes within the Presbyterian Church in America (PCA). They start off with a bit of fun—Jared presents a quiz on judicial cases that have shaped the PCA. Then, the discussion turns serious as they unpack the nuances of BCO 31, addressing questions of jurisdiction, the role of the courts, and the necessity of due process in church discipline.

  42. #77: Best Host Ever (BCO 31 part two)

    March 25, 2025 · 51 minutes

    Ben, Jared, Half-Scott, and Steve are back to finish BCO 31.

  43. #78: The People I Lied to Are Dead (BCO 32 Part One)

    April 1, 2025 · 49 minutes

    Ben, Jared, Scott, and Fred deal with the first six sections of BCO 32.

  44. #79: The People I Lied to Are Dead: Part Three (BCO 32 part two)

    April 8, 2025 · 42 minutes

    Ben, Jared, Scott, and Fred continue their discussion and explanation of BCO 32.

  45. #80: Until I Read Them Out Loud (BCO 33)

    April 15, 2025 · 42 minutes

    Steve Dowling joins the polity bros to work through BCO 33: Special Rules Pertaining to Process Before Sessions.

  46. #81: All of My Secrets Have Been Exposed (BCO 34)

    April 22, 2025 · 50 minutes

    Jared and Scott are joined by RE John Bise to work through matters pertaining to process against TEs.

  47. #82: An Out of Date Bunch of Malarkey (BCO 35 part one)

    April 29, 2025 · 35 minutes

    Ben, Jared, Scott, and Fred begin PCA BCO Chapter 35 on Evidence. They discuss the competency of witnesses, the rights of the accused and accuser, procedures for handling testimony, and the judgment of evidence in church courts.

  48. #83: Bigger Problems Than Testifying in a PCA Court (BCO 35 part two)

    May 6, 2025 · 38 minutes

    Ben, Jared, Scott, and Fred finish out BCO 35.

  49. #84: BCO 36 The Infliction of Church Censures

    May 13, 2025 · 62 minutes

    Dr. Waters joins the guys to discuss the infliction of censures.

  50. #85: BCO 37: The Removal of Censure

    May 27, 2025 · 61 minutes

    Mel Duncan joins the show to help us think through the removal of censures in BCO 27.

  51. #87: It's Almost GA, Where's Our Controversy? (Overtures 2025 Part One)

    June 9, 2025 · 62 minutes

    Alex Ford is back! We quickly put him to work sifting through Overtures with the guys…

  52. #88: Some Sense of Order (Overtures 2025 Part Two)

    June 12, 2025 · 67 minutes

    Alex Ford is back! We quickly put him to work sifting through Overtures with the guys…

  53. #89: Crash Course on the PCA General Assembly

    June 16, 2025 · 40 minutes

    Jared, Scott, and Ben spend time with friend of the show Steve Dowling, discussing the week of General Assembly and what we might expect at the 52nd.

  54. #91: 52nd PCAGA Recap

    July 1, 2025 · 46 minutes

    Ben and Jared hit a few highlights of the 52nd General Assembly, and then Jared is joined by the PCA Archivist Wayne Sparkman for a brief interview.

  55. #92: Regarding Paul Settle

    July 15, 2025 · 42 minutes

    Jared sits down with Mel Duncan and Jason Helopolous to discuss the influential ministry of Rev. Paul Settle.

  56. #94: A Good Church, A Bad Church, and Nowhere (BCO 38)

    July 29, 2025 · 49 minutes

    He’s never introduced, but you can’t deny the dulcet tones of RE Howie Donahoe, who joins Scott and Jared to get into BCO 38.

  57. #95: Put Me Out of My Misery (BCO 39)

    August 5, 2025 · 50 minutes

    It’s all about the modes! Join Scott, Jared, and Fred as the discuss the BCO chapter with the longest title: Modes in Which the Proceedings of Lower Courts Come Under the Supervision of Higher Courts.

  58. #96: Nothing of Substance (RPR w/Thomas Rickard)

    August 12, 2025 · 58 minutes

    Scott and Jared are joined by Thomas Rickard to have (another) discussion about Review of Presbytery Records.

  59. #97: Inept to Do This Alone (BCO 40)

    August 19, 2025 · 58 minutes

    A Ben and Fred duo episode—all about Review and Control.

  60. #99: Never Know When a Party Breaks Out (BCO 42 Part 1)

    September 2, 2025 · 35 minutes

    Scott and Ben are joined Dr. Guy Waters to discuss the first five sections of BCO 42.

  61. #101: Black Jeans & a Navy Blazer (BCO 42 Part 2)

    September 16, 2025 · 31 minutes

    Scott and Ben finish up BCO 42 (with a fair amount of help from Dr. Guy Waters).

  62. #102: We Do Have a Time Limit (BCO 43)

    September 23, 2025 · 53 minutes

    Jared and Scott are joined by Art Sartorius to discuss Complaints.

  63. #104: Officer Training w/David Hall

    October 7, 2025 · 35 minutes

  64. #106: Just Let Them Go (BCO 46)

    October 21, 2025 · 44 minutes

  65. #107: Welcome Per Almquist

    October 28, 2025 · 35 minutes

    Scott and Jared spend some time with Per Almquist, a famliar name to the show.

  66. #108: Instead of Ben a Loud Italian

    November 4, 2025 · 66 minutes

    FAQ w/Fred Greco

  67. #109: Women in the PCA

    November 11, 2025 · 60 minutes

    David Strain and Joshua Walker gather to discuss the role of women in the PCA.

  68. #110: Clarity is Part of Our Job

    November 18, 2025 · 34 minutes

    The guys are joined by Patrick Curles to discuss the Book of Common Worship.

  69. #111: Directories and the ARP

    December 2, 2025 · 40 minutes

    Mark Ross and Ben Glazer join the guys for a discussion about the ARP and worship.

  70. #112: Worship in the OPC with Jonathan Cruse

    December 16, 2025 · 41 minutes

    What Happens When We Worship (Cruse) - Reformation Heritage Books

  71. #113: Worship in the EPC

    December 30, 2025 · 53 minutes

    Go here to see resources from the EPC, including their Book of Order.

  72. #119: Lead My Sheep

    February 17, 2026 · 34 minutes

    Lead My Sheep at PCABookStore

  73. #122: Polity Nerds Stick Together

    March 10, 2026 · 44 minutes

    Jeffrey Choi, a PCA pastor in Los Angeles, discusses the nuances of Overture 37, the role of women in the diaconate, and the implications for PCA polity.

  74. #132: Overtures 2026

    May 15, 2026 · 211 minutes

    Ben , Scott , and Jared are joined by friend of the show Alex Ford to tackle the massive slate of overtures for the 53rd General Assembly. This year, a record 90 overtures (89 new and one referred from last year) are on the docket, covering everything from the diaconate to artificial intelligence.

  75. #133: One Big Beautiful Directory

    May 26, 2026 · 63 minutes

    Ben, Scott, and Jared sit down with members of the committee tasked with revising the PCA’s Directory for Worship: Nate Shurden, Joel St. Clair, and Chad Van Dixhoorn.

  76. #135: AI AIC?

    June 9, 2026 · 57 minutes

    The guys are joined by Joshua Torrey, Frank Cohee, and Adam Parker to discuss the possibility of an Ad Interim Committee on Artificial Intelligence.

  77. #136: Christian Nationalism with David Strain

    June 16, 2026 · 33 minutes

    In this episode, we sit down with David Strain to discuss the PCA’s ad interim committee on Christian Nationalism. We explore the diverse definitions of the movement, the ethical challenges it presents in local congregations, and the committee’s approach to providing pastoral counsel.

  78. #137: Box of Chocolates Effect (GA Debrief)

    June 30, 2026 · 56 minutes

    Ben welcomes Fred Greco, Steve Tipton, and first-time commissioner RE Jonah Cleveland to debrief after the 53rd PCA General Assembly.

  79. #143: A Chapter Called Fred Greco

    September 29, 2026 · 32 minutes

    Ben, Jared, and Scott welcome PCA Stated Clerk Fred Greco back to the show as they kick off a new season working through the Rules of Assembly Operation (RAO) — the “yellow pages” section of the BCO appendices. Fred explains what the RAO actually is: the rulebook for how General Assembly conducts its business, and a window into how the PCA’s permanent committees, agencies, and Standing Judicial Commission operate between assemblies.

  80. #144: You're the Umpire

    October 6, 2026 · 53 minutes

    Jared Nelson and Scott Edburg are joined by Mel Duncan, moderator of the 53rd General Assembly, to walk through the first two chapters of the Rules of Assembly Operations. Chapter 1 covers calling the General Assembly to order, the opening sermon and exhortation, the stated clerk’s enrollment report, and the election of the moderator, including nominating speeches, ballots, and clickers. Chapter 2 turns to the moderator’s duties: presiding, inviting others to preside, calling the next assembly to order, and the floor privileges of former moderators.

  81. #145: The Utility Company of the PCA

    October 13, 2026 · 37 minutes

    Ben and Jared are joined again by PCA Stated Clerk Fred Greco to walk through Chapter 3 of the Rules of Assembly Operation, which covers the Stated Clerk. Fred explains what the job is and isn’t: clerical rather than spiritual leadership (“He’s not the bishop of the PCA”), the qualifications in RAO 3-5, and why the clerk is a trusted source of constitutional advice precisely because he doesn’t take sides.

  82. #146: Broker of Relationships and Resources

    October 20, 2026 · 43 minutes

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Stephen Estock, coordinator of the PCA’s Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM), as the RAO series continues through the permanent committees and agencies. Stephen shares his path from Birmingham to the Air Force, Covenant Seminary, and the pastorate, and how he came to lead CDM, formerly Christian Education and Publications.

  83. #147: ProtoPresbytery

    October 27, 2026 · 43 minutes

    Ben and Jared are joined by Lloyd Kim, coordinator of Mission to the World (MTW), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Lloyd shares his path from Southern California and Westminster Seminary to the Philippines and Cambodia, and how he came to serve in his thirteenth year as coordinator of MTW, the sending arm of the PCA.

  84. #148: From Birthing Babies to Geriatric Care

    November 3, 2026 · 34 minutes

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Dowling, interim coordinator of Mission to North America (MNA), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Steve marks one year in the role (he started October 1, 2025) and explains why the interim period was extended by a year, through next June, and what has changed inside MNA along the way.

  85. #149: Two Keys on the Nuclear Submarine

    November 10, 2026 · 42 minutes

    Jared and Scott are joined by Andrew Rein, coordinator of Reformed University Fellowship (RUF), as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Andrew shares how he came to RUF as a freshman at Vanderbilt in 1996, and how a career in telecom and a capital campaign led him to lead the ministry.

  86. #150: You've Got to Come Visit

    November 17, 2026 · 42 minutes

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Brad Voyles, president of Covenant College, as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Brad shares how he went from Bellhaven and RTS Jackson to Covenant in 2005, serving as vice president for student development before becoming president three and a half years ago.

Submit feedback

Questions, corrections, and comments go to the hosts.